Fans of the Tyneside club are progressively regarding their manager's outfit as an unreliable ally. When everything clicks, they transform into the undisputed entertainers, delivering high-octane exhibitions. Yet, at other times, once-dependable individuals like Sandro Tonali and his teammates completely go missing.
Adding to the frustration is a late-game strategy laced with a worrying streak of panic. Ahead of their holiday fixture to Old Trafford, the facts tell a sobering tale: the team has dropped 13 vital top-flight leverage from leading situations this term and are yet to keep a shutout in 10 straight outings across all competitions. Claiming three points at their famous stadium would represent only their second-ever league success on the travel this year.
On the flip side, a loss has been tasted once in their previous 6 Premier League fixtures, and although occupying a seemingly lowly 11th place, they remain a only 6 marks away from the coveted top four. Factor in an looming two-legged Carabao Cup semi-final against Manchester City and a decent prospect of advancing to the Champions League last 16, and it is simpler to understand the gaffer's measured optimism.
“We don't just have issues,” said the team's manager. “There are assets too. The perspective here is very much half full right now. I realize outside observers might have a opposing take, but I feel we are making progress.”
The challenge persists: will this squad recapture – or perhaps exceed – the heights of the previous campaign's cup glory and European-qualifying standing? Balancing a packed calendar hinders.
This tiredness could explain the failure to maintain a superb first-half showing versus their London rivals, eventually surrendering a 2-0 lead to tie 2-2. Similarly, it is possibly the explanation for a poor display in a damaging loss to arch-rivals the Black Cats, where the side seemed off the pace just days after a grueling Champions League excursion.
Although coaching is clearly the manager's strength, the relentless grind of twice-weekly football has radically cut into crucial coaching hours. This impedes the squad's tactical adjustment to playing with summer signing Nick Woltemade leading the line, rather than the now departed their former star. While immensely skilled, the German forward lacks the same blistering counter-attacking pace or intense pressing.
In fact, the side's signature pressing game has occasionally failed. Fitness issues to crucial engine the Brazilian midfielder have not helped, while expensive arrivals the Swedish winger and Jacob Ramsey have struggled settling after their combined £90m+ transfers.
If a switch to a three-man defense could arguably assist the team, a full-blown backline injury crisis makes that problematic. First-choice full-backs will be missing for the next key fixtures, further testing the team's depth.
At their ferocious peak, they appear virtually unstoppable. The issue is sustaining that fervor for the entire 90 minutes. The go-to plan B of dropping deep into a passive defensive shape has at times been self-destructive.
“That game became anarchic at two-all,” conceded the manager. “But we were going for the victory. We always go out to win.”
What seems called for is a pragmatic solution – one featuring superior possession retention, a engine room adept of controlling the pace, and a sensible readiness to sometimes settle for a point. Yet, a determination to compete on all competitions is stretching finite player resources to their limit.
It may sound sacrilegious to some, but a different strategy in the cup competitions in the initial stages could have alleviated the present fixture congestion. With vital European and league matches on the agenda, the imperative to strategically choose focus areas is growing ever more obvious.
The manager recognized the size of the journey ahead. “When you're involved this club, the pressures are big. Each game is pivotal. There is progress to be made in the Premier League. We're in the Carabao Cup last four, we aim to progress in the Europe and do well in the FA Cup.
“We're moving in the correct path, but we have a great deal of improvement to do to become the regularly winning team we want to be. The ability to string together winning runs has deserted us so far.
“The objective is to attain that standard we know we're capable of. My feeling is that the assurance we can achieve it is returning. But now we have to demonstrate it. It ain't all doom and gloom currently, but the coming period will decide a lot.”